There was a 4 hour CBS mini-series movie about the New Life Community Church in Sayville and how its elder, the evil Dr. Reza, shot and killed a woman in her sleep. The murder was typical for the area. The murderer said he was under a "Delusion," got more and more crazy, and then shot a family member in her sleep, just like what happened to the DeFeos in nearby Amityville. The killing was extremely violent, he shot and strangled her in her bed.
Although CBS billed the movie as "True Life" the names were changed when the Killer Robert Reza with the backing of Sayville residents threatened CBS. CBS left the script alone except for the names. Stephen Siegel, of Smithtown, was one of the writers, and according to Newsday he said, CBS "hired me specifically to develop the real life story," and "brought a lot of intimidation in the form of [members of] the church congregation" on the mistress not to testify. CBS said, "This true crime love story is based on the chilling story of a woman's murder that consumes a small town..." Actress Katie Boland, who played Elly in the movie, also starred in "Salem Witch Trials." What made the movie so interesting was how so many people in the village rallied around and supported the crazed killer.
![]() |
Olympia Dukakis as the mother. | John Bourgeois as the Reverend. |
|
Marcia Gay Harden as the Mistress. She played the Church organ, and the organ of Dr. Reza. |
From cbs.com:
This true crime love story is based on the chilling story of a
woman's murder that consumes a small town and its church community after
the woman's influential and respected husband is deemed the primary suspect -
and his ex-mistress reveals their formerly clandestine affair. The continuing
investigation tests the resilience of the bond between the mistress and her
estranged husband -- as the jailed suspect attempts to discredit and implicate
them before the trial.
Feeling suffocated by a marriage in which she feels increasingly unappreciated
and misunderstood, Jenny Moran (Harden) finds herself in secret awe of the
family life and upscale lifestyle of the successful Dr. Stephen Carrow
(Williams) who worships at the church where she is employed as an organist.
When Jenny innocently chooses to bring her ailing father to the highly regarded
Stephen for a consultation, she quickly finds herself relishing the newfound
attention of the charming doctor. Their relationship continues and intensifies
after her father's death. Soon, Jenny shocks her husband, Matt (Gary Basaraba),
her children and mother (Dukakis) by leaving home. At Stephen's urging she even
agrees to accuse Matt of abuse. Calling Jenny's move a part of God's plan,
Stephen begins an illicit affair with the adoring Jenny -- and tells her
he will soon leave his wife.
When Stephen's wife is fatally shot at home, his alibi is quickly disproved --
and he ends up confessing to the murder. But his temporary insanity plea is in
jeopardy when the shocked Jenny dutifully informs the police of their affair.
Vehemently denying the liaison, Stephen challenges Jenny's mental health -- and
begins a campaign, with the help of his devoted church circle, to discredit and
humiliate her. Despite Jenny's disloyalty and her continued resistance to return
to him, Matt cannot bear to see how emotionally fragile Jenny has become -- and
vows to protect her from the church members who will stop at nothing to get
Stephen acquitted.
http://www.findarticles.com/cf_dls/m4PRN/2001_Dec_17/80858749/p1/article.jhtml
From Newsday:
2002 Newsday, Inc.
February 8, 2002 Friday ALL EDITIONS
SECTION: NEWS, Pg. A12
Murder, They Rewrote;
CBS changes names, places in retelling of Reza case
Here we go again: Another sensational Long Island murder is about to become the
basis of another television miniseries, this one focusing on the 1990 murder of
Bayport resident Marilyn Reza.
Viewers who studied Newsday or watched Court TV a decade ago will recall the
particulars of this murder, but CBS' "Guilty Hearts" - airing Sunday and
Wednesday - will not make it easy. The TV movie uses fictional names for both
Robert Reza, the pulmonary specialist who was convicted in 1992 of the murder of
his wife, as well as other key figures in the case. In addition, the miniseries
is set in Illinois. Reza was tried and eventually convicted in State Supreme
Court in Riverhead, while Kathy Senese, his onetime mistress who became a star
witness against him, had first met Reza in a Sayville church where she was an
organist. Stephen Siegel, a Smithtown resident who co-wrote the screenplay, said
yesterday that Reza's lawyer had threatened legal action against CBS; a
spokeswoman for the network confirmed the names had been changed "for legal
reasons." Siegel, 40, an adjunct instructor in screenwriting at New York
University, said CBS "hired me specifically to develop the real life story," and
added that in his research, he discovered that Reza - serving 25 years to life
in an upstate prison - "brought a lot of intimidation in the form of [members
of] the church congregation" on Senese not to testify. Reza, an elder at
Sayville's New Community Church, was highly regarded there, though his efforts
to force Senese not to testify failed.
In the telefilm, a person named Jenny Moran (Marcia Gay Harden) becomes
infatuated with Stephen Carrow (Treat Williams). He later murders his wife, is
caught and pleads temporary insanity.
The murder case: Senese became infatuated with Reza, who treated her father for
cancer in 1985, and their affair began in 1990. She briefly left her husband and
then returned after Reza's arrest. Reza later confessed that he had strangled
and shot his wife of 22 years as she slept in her bed on Dec. 12, 1990. He also
pleaded insanity.
Sign the Guest Book View the Guest Book
This is a listing of what is important to people's faith. Prayer, church chorus, praying,
and angels in Sayville. Worship in the town. Saints in the church. Churches in
the area. Scandals with ministers, bishops, priests, nuns, convents and a
convent. The seven sacraments provided are baptism, marriage, death,
communion, confirmation, etc. Mary apparitions and sightings in Sayville and
Long Island. Miracle in Suffolk County. Miracles in the Town of Islip started
the beatification. The pope, bishop, and archbishop. Information about the
Rockville Center diocese. Friar and the deacon, with the help of lay persons or
a layperson. Weird experiments, and an experiment that went wild. Canal
front property available in the area, contact the Sayville Real Estate agent
with the listing. Sayville mortgage brokers. Doctors in the area, and
landscapers and day care centers, with motels and hotels near the downtown, Main
St. Bible study at the church parsonage. Long Island NY. Suffolk County includes
the town of Islip. Weddings and funerals. Angel of the choir. Hallucinations
caused by insanity. Hymns of the houses of worship, and the
tent revival. Scandalous behavior at the church. Scandals
involving practitioners. Medical doctor involved in malpractice gets sued.
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH OF SAYVILLE, GRACE CHAPEL
ASSEMBLY OF GOD, GOSPEL COMMUNITY CHURCH, ST. ANN'S EPISCOPAL CHURCH, ST.
LAWRENCE THE MARTYR R.C. CHURCH, ST. JOHN'S LUTHERAN CHURCH SAYVILLE,
CONGREGATIONAL UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST , UNITED METHODIST CHURCH OF SAYVILLE ,
WEST SAYVILLE REFORMED BIBLE CHURCH, WORLD OUTREACH CHURCH OF GOD, SAYVILLE
JEWISH COMMUNITY CENTER Youth pastor for church youth programs. Senior Citizen
programs at the church at the church ministry. Sunday school available for
religion instruction, and student ministry and a bible study. Pastor available
for weddings. Worship and meditation. Reverend
Dan Heemstra gives great sermons at the
church service. The sermon on church was great. Here is the place for
information on Jehovah Witness's.
Directory of Sayville doctors, trains hobby show toy stores toy store
hobbies physicians, orthodontists, Chiropractors and dentists in Sayville. Art
Galleries, Art Gallery, Book Keeping, Accounting Favors/Glassware Newspapers
Animal Hospitals Ferry Transportation Paint Apparel Clothiers Ski equipment
water ski and water skiing , Boutiques Fences Photography Appliances Gift Shops
Real Estate Auto Repair Court Reporters Hardware Restaurants Automobile Sales
Health Yoga Seafood Wholesaler Clam Buyers, Bookkeeping Holistic Services
Spa and Skin Care Boat scooter bikes, bicycles rental and sales s Insurance
Agencies Shoes Chiropractors Irrigation Telephone Equipment, Computers and
Internet Jewelers jewelry, TV, vice, mice, video, CD, DVD, and Satellite
Contracting Massage Therapy Wallpaper Cosmetics Music Lessons Web Design Crafts
Churches Printers Attorney At Law Hairdressers
Greater Sayville and Islip Area Business Directory:
Arby’s, Normandy InnJoes’ Garage Fabric Shop Patchworks Sayville Learning Center, BOCES, Wind Mill, Quilting Gallery windmill, Vanderbuilt Quality Fences The Car Shoppe of Sayville DMT Doctors, nurses Bookkeeping White Water Marine INC. Chiropractors Home Internet Consulting Service Oakdale Computer, Inc. EVI T.D.K Heating & Irrigation Corp Francine's Cosmetique Friendly’s, Sayville Ferry Service. A Basketfull A Gift and Gourmet Basket Shop Coming Home To Country LTD Health Club Gym New Image Hair Salon Zion's Hair Design and Mini Day Spa Brinkmann True Value Hardware Blue Point Ice Cream Factory Inner Light Yoga Center Sayville Holistic Services Pet Shop, Pets, Thurber Appliance & TV Dennis , Jr., Esq general practice Matrimonial and Family Law, Criminal Law and Personal Injury, Wills and Estates, Real Estate Law, Elder Law, Law Offices of Carvel Ice Cream transactions and litigation Commercial/Corporate Law; Wills, Trusts & Estates, injury, Real Estate, litigation, divorce Commercial and Residential; Land Use . Fua Wai Chinese Food, Windmill Graphics, Sayville Pizza, Sal’s Pizza, Sylvan Learning Center McDonald’s, Burger King, K-Mart, Michael's Auto Repair Sayville Ford, Island Hills Golf Club Golf show and supples Make-Up Application, Body Waxing, Spa Packages, and a full line of Salon Quality Products. Stone therapy, Therapeutic Nail Care, Massage Packages, Beauty and Wellness services Top Quality Hair Styling, Skin Care, alternative therapies irrigation Homeopathy Stress Management Clinical Hypnosis Vitamin, Herbs, food supplements Ear candling SuJuk Acupuncture Iridology Urinalysis lab test Enzyme Therapy Ariculotherapy Massage Therapy Facials , Reflexology, Healing Arts, Aromatherapy AC Edwards, Inc. Percy Hoek Inc.insurance agency providing auto, home, life, and commercial Insurance. We specialize in Fire Island and coastal insurance. Sprinklers Kay Cameron Jewelers Essential Therapies Sonny's Piano & Music Studio Suffolk County News - Mark Nolan is the editor Van Kemenade Paint and Wallpaper - Commercial Paint Supply Jo-Art Photographers - photography Weeks & Reichel The Print Smith Barry M. Schwartz, CBR Prudential Long Island Realty Office - Buying or selling a home or homes Century 21 Bay's Edge Realty, Inc. Eileen Meehan Realty Real estate brokers and agents. Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate Village Fish Market - Seafood Zion's Hair Design and Mini Day Spa Polished Skincare Lounge Lakeside Day Spa Elaine's Shoes Bruno Realty Consultants George’s TV and satellite Pre-Owned Bought & Sold. Music Lessons and instruments. Pianos guitars, violins Appliances Sprinkler Company High Speed Satellite Internet Surround Sound installations Service installation moves programming business telephone repair equipment manufacturers, partner, fiber-optices voicemail, on hold messaging Installation of data cables including cat5 Repairs/Renovations Water Mains installed West Sayville.
Service Available in the greater Sayville area:
Air conditioning service, alterations, alarm systems installation, car alarm installation, aluminum siding, driveway blacktops, attorneys, beauty supplies, blinds, cabinets, business records, carpet installing, carpet cleaning, carpet repair, closets, clinic, copier repair and service, dating service, draperies, plumber, plumbing emergency and emergencies, electrician, jewelry repair, hospice, real estate buyers broker, movers, janitorial service, maid service, babysitter, babysitting, day care, preschool, private school, roofing, landscaping, plumbing, handyman, security guard, attorney, lawyer, drug store, druggist, dentists, dentist, flowers, engravers, engineer, engineers, engraver, funeral parlor, funerals, event planning, catering, caterer, used cars, private detective, private investigator, escrow service, employment agency, convenience store, doors, dieticians, interior decorators, dental, pets, dog breeder, dive shop, MD, bank, banks, hair cutters, barbers, beauty salons, floors, florists, florist, clubs, social service organizations, herbs, health food, gold, silver, rare coins, houses, insurance, insurance agency, insurance agents, ice, cleaning, dry cleaning, laundry service, homeopaths, home loans, auto repair, airplanes, guns, sporting goods, screen printing, printers, grocers, supermarkets, food, free delivery, pizza delivery, fitness center, flea market, gemologist, gemologists, auto parts, heating oil, investments, financial planner and financial planning, office space, post office, mail boxes, kitchens, legal, karate, land, locksmiths, marina, marine, marinas, medical supplies, midwives, Mobile homes, mildew removal, cameras, weddings, bar mitzvahs, bat mitzvahs, bar mitzvah, bat mitzvah, mobile phones, cell phones, maternity clothes, maps, books, magazines, book store, Sayville Books, motorcycles, monograms, specialty advertising, nursery, orthopedic, office supplies, paint, paving, pools, physicians, surgeons, DO, pediatrics, urology, vascular, plastic surgery, allergies, art, private detectives, radio, restaurants, Chinese, German, Indian, Mexican, Yiddish, Japanese, Bistros, Bistro, Steakhouse, Seafood, Italian, French, Travel Agency, travel agencies, car rentals, wigs, visa, passport photos, yachts, moving, vinyl repair, water purifiers, wallpaper installation, veterinarian, windows, Town of Islip, Oakdale, Bayport, Holbrook, Bohemia, Suffolk County, Long Island Melissa Joan Hart biography & bio, pictures hart flower-florist flower-lily flower-funeral flower-Sayville flower george canine-story gy somoza burie giant sachem book keystone prom strange Keystone two reel comedies. Two real comedy.